Professor: Investigator Coached Roach
By Kimball Perry, Post staff reporter
September 21, 2001
A psychology professor criticized Cincinnati police for their interview methods
and noted Police Officer Stephen Roach reacted naturally when he shot and killed
Police Specialist Charles Beaver, who testified Wednesday that Roach lied to
them about the April shooting, was pushing Roach to reach a specific conclusion
at a time when Roach was vulnerable, said professor
William Lewinski, called by the
defense in Roach's trial on misdemeanor charges of negligent homicide and
obstructing official business.
''Specialist Beaver had an agenda which he drove home throughout the interview .
. . that it was an accidental discharge, that it was an accident,'' Lewinski
testified Thursday in Roach's trial.
Beaver's agenda, Lewinski charged, led to him to conclude Roach was being
deceptive. ''It was a diatribe, a lecture, an extensive coercive interrogation
Wednesday, Beaver admitted on the stand he was coaching Roach, hoping to get him
to admit to a lesser crime instead of remaining quiet and being charged with a
more serious one.
Lewinski criticized Beaver for not letting Roach see the videotapes from police
cruiser cameras that showed scenes of the shooting before questioning Roach a
second time, in an April 10 interview, about the incident. Instead, Lewinski
charged, Beaver set Roach up by asking questions and getting answers he believed
would be contradicted by the videos.
After Roach saw the videos, he admitted he shot Thomas after the teen came
around the corner of a building and startled him.
Prosecutors contend Beaver's tactics are good investigative techniques.
Roach shot Thomas, 19, on April 7 as officers trying to arrest the unarmed teen
on misdemeanor warrants chased him through dark Over- the-Rhine streets. The
shooting touched off three days of rioting.
Lewinski and another expert called by defense attorney Merlyn Shiverdecker
testified Roach reacted exactly as he should have.
''What happened to Officer Roach is he made the most serious mistake, and he
doesn't know why he did it,'' Lewinski said, noting it's natural that Roach
should have memory lapses about the incident. ''Officers who shoot in those
situations don't understand why they shoot,'' he said.
Another expert, forensic optometrist Paul Michel, said Roach's brain would have
interpreted what his eyes saw - when Roach said he saw Thomas reach for the
waistband of his baggy sweat pants - as a threat and his police training would
have become instinctive. That Thomas was a threat ''was his reality at that
moment,'' Michel said.
''He is functioning on the basis he has seen a gun. This is the way the brain is
preprogramed.'' Shiverdecker expects to finish his case today. Closing arguments
are set for Monday afternoon.
SEE RELATED STORIES BELOW
Police Investigator Grilled
Admits steering officer's account
By Kimball Perry, Cincinnati Post staff reporter
September 20, 2001
Cincinnati Police Detective Charles Beaver admitted during testimony Wednesday
that he tried to steer the statement of Stephen Roach to keep the young officer
from getting charged with a major crime after he shot an unarmed teen-ager April
7 in Over-the-Rhine.
''My purpose and reason was to prevent Officer Roach from stepping into
something more serious,'' Beaver testified. ''I didn't want Officer Roach to get
jammed up with a felony, a serious criminal offense or something like that . . .
when the evidence pointed to an accidental discharge.''
Beaver was the police investigator who questioned Roach after he shot and killed
Timothy Thomas, 19, as he fled police trying to arrest him on 14 misdemeanor
Beaver's dramatic testimony was the centerpiece for the prosecution's case
against Roach, who is charged with negligent homicide and obstruction of
official business. If convicted of both, he faces a maximum of nine months in
Beaver noted how Roach gave them three different versions of how the shooting
happened until finally, after being confronted with videotapes of the incidents
and other evidence, admitted he accidentally shot Thomas when the teen startled
him by coming around a corner of a dark alley near Republic Street.
His problem with Roach, Beaver added, wasn't necessarily that the 27-year-old
officer violated some of his training - by pulling his gun before he entered the
alley and placing his finger on the trigger instead of the trigger guard - but
that he gave different versions of what happened. ''I would have pulled (a gun)
myself,'' Beaver said.
Beaver spent much of the afternoon defending himself from questions by Roach's
attorney, Merlyn Shiverdecker, who was trying to discredit Beaver's earlier
testimony that he believed Roach was being ''untruthful to me'' about how the
shooting took place.
Beaver's ''I can't remember'' reply to a Shiverdecker question caused the
defense attorney to ask him snidely: ''You're not intentionally trying to
deceive or hide something, are you?''
Beaver, who had asked Roach a similar question during his interview, responded
with a smile.
Shiverdecker objected to several of Beaver's answers, telling Hamilton County
Municipal Court Judge Ted Winkler that Beaver wasn't clairvoyant and continued
to give ''self-serving platitudes'' instead of answers.
Special Prosecutor Stephen McIntosh planned to rest his case today.
Shiverdecker planned to take most of the day for his expert witnesses - who will
testify about how human eyes work in the dark and how the human mind operates in
dangerous situations. The case could conclude by late Friday.
Winkler then will consider the evidence before rendering a verdict that is
expected early next week.
Detective: Roach Lied About Shooting
By Kimball Perry, Cincinnati Post staff reporter
September 19, 2001
Cincinnati Police Officer Stephen Roach lied to police investigators to cover
himself after fatally shooting Timothy Thomas, an investigator said today.
''(Roach) realized he made a mistake and was trying to justify his actions,''
Cincinnati Police Detective Charles Beaver testified.
''(He was) being untruthful to me.''
Beaver said he and another homicide detective first interviewed Roach about five
hours after the April 7 shooting.
In that statement, Roach provided a detailed description of Thomas being in a
pitch-dark alley near Republic Street in Over-the-Rhine reaching deep into his
sweatpants, pulling out a clenched fist, holding what Roach thought was a gun
and making aggressive movements toward the officer.
Even at that interview, Beaver said he didn't believe Roach's version of the
''To me, it sent up a red flag,'' Beaver said, noting that most people
interviewed after a shooting can't ''recall and describe in immense amount of
detail'' all of the incident.
Police then reviewed videotapes taken from police cruisers at the scene that
night, had them enhanced and slowed down and reviewed the videotape frame by
Much of the videotape contradicted Roach's initial statement of those three
''There's just no feasible time frame or way that version, the version Officer
Roach gave, (happened),'' Beaver said.
The tape shows:
Roach entering the alley with his gun already drawn; he earlier told
investigators his gun was holstered until he saw Thomas reach into his pants.
Roach said Thomas took several aggressive steps toward him with his arm
extended. That couldn't have happened, Beaver noted, based on how Thomas' body
fell after the shooting.
Roach said he stopped to draw his gun on Thomas. The video shows Roach never
stopped running even as a muzzle flash shot through the dark alley.
''It almost seemed to us, we discussed it, a very well-rehearsed statement,''
The investigators called Roach in for a second interview three days later ''to
find out what really happened,'' Beaver said to- day.
Again, Roach essentially repeated his first statement - until Beaver showed him
the videotape and said he didn't believe Roach.
''I'm worried about you jamming yourself up here,'' Beaver said in the taped
statement of that interview with Roach. ''I don't want to doubt you, but it
don't add up,'' Beaver said on a tape of the follow-up interview.
''I straight-up think it was an accident,'' he told Roach.
On the tape, Beaver even invoked the November death of Roger Owensby Jr., who
died after police put him in a choke hold, the tape shows.
Had Officers Robert ''Blaine'' Jorg and Patrick Caton not invoked their
Constitutional right against self-incrimination, they may not have been indicted
on such serious charges, he said on the tape.
Jorg is charged with involuntary manslaughter - a felony - and assault. Caton
faces a misdemeanor charge of assault in the Owensby killing. On the tape,
Beaver suggested to Roach the shooting happened because he was startled and not
trying to ''cover yourself with some kind of story.''.
Roach then asked for a break in the interview and privately talked to Fraternal
Order of Police attorney Steve Lazarus, Beaver testified today.
After that, Roach talked again to police on audiotape and admitted the shooting
was ''an accident.''
''I didn't intend to pull the trigger,'' Roach said after meeting with his
The accidental shooting, Roach said, happened because he was startled by Thomas
quickly coming around the corner of the building.
''He jerked up and I jerked when he jerked. Unfortunately, my finger was on the
trigger when I jerked,'' Roach said on the tape.
Beaver said in court that Roach making the final statement may have resulted in
''I figured they'd end up going with more serious charges,'' Beaver said.
Roach was indicted on misdemeanor charges of negligent homicide for the fatal
shooting and obstructing official business for giving different versions of the
story. He faces a maximum sentence of nine months in prison if convicted.
Thomas' death touched off protests and rioting followed by a citywide curfew.
accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, this material is distributed
without profit or payment to those who have expressed a prior interest in
receiving this information for non-profit research and educational purposes
©2004 The Police Policy Studies Council. All rights reserved.